Return rate before margin

With samples on the table, margin is the first number people compute. But what decides whether a product is viable over a year is usually the return rate. A high margin that loses half its orders to returns is not a margin.

My order now: ask what would trigger a return — sizing, colour, finish, or simply a mismatch with expectations. If nobody can answer, I test in small batches and don't stock up.

Recalculate the real margin

The first margin you compute is almost always wrong. Shipping, packaging, platform fees, after-sales cost and customer service time all need to be spread in. Only what remains can fund a promotion.

I split cost into three blocks and fill them in one by one, never from memory:

  • Product cost: purchase price, packaging, spoilage
  • Fulfilment cost: shipping, storage, returns
  • Running cost: fees, promotion, service hours

The last check: can I explain it

If a product's advantage can only be described as cheaper or prettier, I set it aside. Being able to say which situation it solves is what makes a product page writable and a service reply possible.

Most products don't fail because they're bad, but because buyers can't see why it fits them.